San Francisco Chronicle, OPEN FORUM, Friday, July 22, Carol Leigh When hundreds of federal and state agents descended on massage parlors in San Francisco earlier this month, declaring some women sex slaves, another story was obscured by this moral panic: This rescue operation was not necessarily in the best interests of pzrlor women.
Harris claims that " victims were discovered". In the early '80s, I worked at several massage parlors in San Francisco.
Massage program -- sf department of public health
It wouldn't end the exploitation of migrants that accompanies illegal migration, but it would mean they would be less dependent on francisfo criminal underground. Now in federal custody, the Sna of these women is based on their "innocence" about prostitution, according to Bradley Scholzman, acting assistant U. In academic and human rights circles there is a great deal of criticism of the anti-trafficking strategies and perspectives of the US government, but this criticism has received little notice in the media.
San Francisco must provide a venue for workers to discuss grievances, while protecting identity of those workers. I also hear stories about contract labor and debts, and about the repercussions women face when they don't make the payments. They can be men or women, young or old, American or from abroad, with or without legal status. You can help bring the perpetrators to justice.
'very well connected': massage parlor sting revealed a network of prostitution, trafficking
Instead, they are forced into prostitution, domestic servitude, farm or factory labor, or other types of forced labor. But the combination of migrant workers' fraancisco and prohibitions on erotic massage create a particularly sensitive situation. After recent highly publicized arrests in San Francisco massage parlors, Leigh reveals the hypocrisies behind these rescue efforts. In her article, D.
Massage parlor – cbs san francisco
The legislation offers protection to victims and allows law enforcement agencies parlo investigate and prosecute human trafficking. This will do more good and less harm than raids and special visas bequeathed to a few. San Francisco Chronicle, OPEN FORUM, Friday, July 22, Carol Leigh When hundreds of federal and state agents descended on massage parlors in San Francisco earlier this month, declaring some women sex slaves, another story was obscured by this moral panic: This rescue operation was not necessarily kassage the best interests of these women.
Plus, although the government claims to offer special visas to protect these women, maswage order to qualify for these visas, federal law states that she remain only as long as she assists with the investigation and prosecution of the traffickers.
'johns' in san francisco sit down for a class on the sex trade
framcisco Exploitation is defined as sex trafficking in which a commercial sex act is induced by force, fraud or coercion, or if the person forced to perform such an act is under 18 years of age. The tourist business in the area benefits from the massage industry, so it's time to acknowledge the contribution of the women who work in it. Leigh par,or also advised on local legislation addressing massage industry regulation.
The complex story behind the headlines is about migrant workers who have made various deals in exchange for jobs and transportation to the United States.
Are we following the policies of the Board of Supervisors resolution establishing San Francisco as a "city of refuge"? This cooperation and ultimate deportation could result in extreme jeopardy for the migrant and her family. Reviews on Asian Massage Parlors in San Francisco, CA - Xin Xing Massage, Suchada Thai Massage, Massage Mission, Magic Massage, La Biang Thai.
How to avoid the pitfalls of law-enforcement intervention, how to help those who want assistance to escape debt bondage and other forms of abuse, without singling out Asian women in the massage industry as a target for police and further victimizing the entire community?
I hear stories about strong women trying to make their way, establishing families and gaining legal status in this country. I liked working in them, and I especially masssage spending time with the other women, who were upbeat, smart and resilient, nothing like the stereotypes. The city could thus begin to take some responsibility for the welfare of these women.
Some may have originally "participated voluntarily," but may still be victimized through abusive working conditions and when payments are not applied fairly to the worker's debt. Some of the workers may be relatively satisfied with these arrangements, even though they are vulnerable and can be exploited. DTL from a different perspective.
She has demonstrated some support for justice for women in the sex industry, although her portrayal of trafficking is inaccurate, even contradicted by recent US government reports.
The public is ready for these complexities. More about California's AB22 Although AB22 specifically targets forced labor in general and forced labor in the context of the sex industry, and NOT VOLUNTARY sex work, early versions of this bill were confusing and actually inadvertently, I assume made it a crime to even unknowingly be a customer of any businesses that may include trafficked workers. San Francisco Sues Massage Parlor Accused Of Running A BrothelThe city of San Francisco is suing a Financial District massage parlor alleging that the.
with massage parlors, has instead subjected San Francisco's entire Combs and the seven-member San Francisco Massage Council. Everyone has a role to play in combating human trafficking. Activists call for decriminalization as a way to apply labor codes and oversee these industries. Since then, I have followed the news and rumors about the parlors.
For example, francsco repeats the estimate of 50, people trafficked to the United States this year.
Massage parlor prostitution is being charged as a serious crime in california - www.sicilylife.eu
Informer San Francisco police officer Francis Hogue was convicted of kidnapping and sexually assaulting a massage-parlor worker. Chronicle reporter Heather Knight explained their status in a story July 3: "The women can at any time decide to return to South Korea, although law enforcement officials could then declare them a 'material witness' to the case, forcing them to stay in the United States without any benefits. We rely on tips from the public to take down human trafficking organizations.
The SF Chronicle report holds that "In a series of searches begun Thursday, investigators said they found more than women working as prostitutes at 10 San Francisco massage parlors. Until we can begin to support rights for migrant workers and craft policies to support their needs to work, we are stuck in a quagmire that attracts, then rescues "innocent victims. Harris seems to be asserting that all the above were 'victims.
Hundreds of massage therapists cited in crackdown, as practitioners fear for future in san francisco - mission local
But before we buy into the "sex slave" melodrama, franciscoo should consider the complexities of sex work, migration and trafficking. Migrants could greatly benefit from real justice and equity in terms of immigration law: options for refugee status, enforcement of labor laws and a fair system of migrant-work visas. Over the years, factions -- from gangs to the police -- have taken advantage of these women.
estimates placed the of persons trafficked to the United States on an annual basis closer to 50, My fellow advocates are concerned however, that in it's current form AB22 does not sufficiently address sensitivities in issues of confidentiality for victims. Throughoutlocal newspapers ran s of gangs robbing and shaking down massage parlors.
Perhaps the District Attorney could revisit our concerns and support our recommended changes.